Last June, I had written to both New York Senators about the Newdow ruling by the 9th circuit court (re: Pledge of Allegiance) to ask that they not blindly reject the courts decision, but to read the ruling (which seems pretty solidly argued). I received a form letter thanking me for my opinion from Senator Schumer. Here is what Sen. Clinton sent me:
********************************************************
Thank you for writing. Your thoughts on the recent decision by the
Appeals Court of the Ninth Circuit regarding the constitutionality of the
pledge of allegiance are very important to me and I appreciate that you
have taken the time to share them with me.
I believe that the Court misinterpreted the intent of the framers of the
Constitution and instead undermined one of the bedrock values of our
democracy, that we are indeed “one nation under God,” as embodied in the
pledge of allegiance to the flag of the United States. It is my hope that
this wrong and unfair decision will be promptly appealed and overturned.
That is why I am supporting S. 292, the Pledge of Allegiance resolution.
While our men and women in uniform are battling overseas and defending us
here at home to preserve the freedom that we all cherish for our country
and its citizens, we should never forget the blessings of Divine
Providence that undergird our nation. That includes the freedom to recite
the pledge of allegiance in our nation’s schools. Our government does not
impose faith on its citizens. There is no moral or Constitutional
argument why our pledge of allegiance cannot acknowledge our commonly held
belief that ours is one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and
justice for all.
If you would like to respond to my e-mail or contact me via e-mail about
this or any other subject, please use my web response form at
http://clinton.senate.gov/email_form.html. Because of the size of my
constituency and the growing number who choose to communicate through
e-mail, I have selected the web form as the fairest and most equitable
system to respond to e-mail messages. E-mails that are sent as a direct
response to my outgoing e-mail fall outside the system and do not receive
a response.
Again, thank you for writing. Please check my website at
http://clinton.senate.gov for regular updates on this and other important
issues being discussed before the United States Senate.
Sincerely yours,
Hillary Rodham Clinton